The Quebec Child Support Guidelines are held to be discriminatory by the Superior Court

Jun 10, 2011

Honourable Justice Diane Marcelin of the Superior Court determined on May 26 2011 that the Quebec Child Support Guidelines are discriminatory to divorcing or divorced mothers. Judge Marcelin called upon the Quebec Government to change the Guidelines voluntarily, and she declared that the  infringement of the constitutional rights of divorced mothers is justified under section 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms because of cooperative federalism.

The adoption of the Quebec Child Support Guidelines under the aegis of the Divorce Act was contested by a group of divorced mothers who got together to challenge the law by reason of the violation of their equality rights, guaranted under section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which is caused to the children whose two parents reside in Quebec. This group of mothers, and their children, with the support of our firm, demonstrated to the Court that the quantum of child support established under the Federal Child Support Guidelines is much more generous, and the conditions for an application for child support protect children much more than under the Quebec law. The petitioners asked that the Federal Guidelines apply instead of the Quebec Guidelines in all cases governed by the Divorce Act (the nullity of this Decree was requested by means of a motion for declaratory judgment).

We have filed an appeal of the judgment, arguing that once a provision of law is discriminatory, it cannot be “saved” by the doctrine of “cooperative federalism.”  The Attorneys General of Quebec and Canada, as well as one of the fathers, have also filed cross-appeals. We await a hearing date within the next few months.

It is absurd and tragic that Canadian children whose two parents reside in Quebec cannot benefit from the generosity of the standard that applies all across Canada, just not here!

Québec Family Law Reform Leaves Most Unwed Couples Unprotected

Me Anne-France Goldwater, senior partner of Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, wishes to express her deep disappointment following the Québec government’s tabling of long-awaited family law reform last month with Bill 56, the Act respecting...

Common law spouses: Me Goldwater meets the Minister of Justice

Goldwater, Dubé, a leader in Canadian family law since 1981, and its senior partner, Me Anne-France Goldwater, would like to thank Me Simon Jolin-Barrette, Québec Minister of Justice and Government House Leader, for meeting with the firm's founding partner on August...

Goldwater, Dubé welcomes senior litigator Me Daniel Romano

Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, and its founder, Me Anne-France Goldwater, are pleased to welcome Me Daniel Romano to its team of senior litigators. He is an established Montréal-based lawyer whose multidisciplinary practice, rigorous work...

Peace bond (article 810 of the Criminal Code)

In the complex world of Canadian law, the commitment to not disturb public order plays a crucial role. This commitment, more commonly known as "810," stems from Article 810 of the Criminal Code. The majority of cases involving crimes against a person, such as assault...

Longueuil Deer: Me Goldwater’s Arguments Against the Slaughter

Read the Court of Appeal judgment here. Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, and its senior partner Me Anne-France Goldwater, will be heard by the Quebec Superior Court in the new year to defend a cause that continues to capture the public’s...