Quebec Superior Court flogs Youth Protection for suspending parent visits

May 1, 2020

Read the Quebec Superior judgment here.

Read the decree from the Health Minister of Quebec here.

In a scathing judgment rendered this week, Quebec Superior Court Judge Hon. France Bergeron criticized the province’s Director of Youth Protection (DYP) for suspending a parent’s visits throughout the COVID-19 pandemic; in one notable case, a microbiology specialist was barred from seeing her children despite following public health guidelines and having a judgment in her favour granting her supervised access.

“Melanie”, whose identity is being protected in accordance with the Youth Protection Act, retained the services of Me Anne-France Goldwater, senior partner, Goldwater, Dubé, when the DYP informed her that she could not visit her two children, temporarily under DYP care, due to the declaration of a province-wide health emergency on March 13, 2020.

Parents visiting their children under supervision, the DYP declared, constituted “a threat to the health of the entire population,” and can only be allowed to see their children in exceptional circumstances, which the DYP determined based on internal guidelines not vetted by the Minister of Health. Judge Bergeron was critical of the failure of the DYP to disclose its internal guidelines, which, in any event, were demonstrated to be out of line with the Justice Ministry and Health Ministry Guidelines which prioritize the respect of all parental visitation rights, even during the pandemic.

The DYP had taken upon itself, without colour of right, to develop its own internal guidelines without the authority or consent of the Minister of Justice or the Minister of Health. Goldwater argued that the DYP has no more right to disobey a judgment on access rights than any other person.

Melanie, a scientist herself, along with the children’s grandmother tasked with supervising the visits, committed to taking the necessary precautions outlined by public health authorities, and obtained consent from the children’s father to continue visits. The father explained the children wanted to spend time with their mother in her own home, and they missed her.

Guidelines issued by the Ministry of Health and Social Services also specify that the rule for the DYP is that visits can and should take place, so long as all parties take the appropriate health precautions, as Melanie did, to protect public health.

In addition to the illegal overreach and disregard for parental rights, Judge Bergeron commented on the misplaced reliance by the DYP on technology. Apple’s FaceTime video conferencing platform, the Court noted, is not an adequate substitute for in-person parental affection.

Photo: Morgan Harris // Unsplash

Common law spouses: Me Goldwater meets the Minister of Justice

Goldwater, Dubé, a leader in Canadian family law since 1981, and its senior partner, Me Anne-France Goldwater, would like to thank Me Simon Jolin-Barrette, Québec Minister of Justice and Government House Leader, for meeting with the firm's founding partner on August...

Goldwater, Dubé welcomes senior litigator Me Daniel Romano

Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, and its founder, Me Anne-France Goldwater, are pleased to welcome Me Daniel Romano to its team of senior litigators. He is an established Montréal-based lawyer whose multidisciplinary practice, rigorous work...

Peace bond (article 810 of the Criminal Code)

In the complex world of Canadian law, the commitment to not disturb public order plays a crucial role. This commitment, more commonly known as "810," stems from Article 810 of the Criminal Code. The majority of cases involving crimes against a person, such as assault...

Longueuil Deer: Me Goldwater’s Arguments Against the Slaughter

Read the Court of Appeal judgment here. Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, and its senior partner Me Anne-France Goldwater, will be heard by the Quebec Superior Court in the new year to defend a cause that continues to capture the public’s...

Goldwater, Dubé welcomes new lawyer with dual expertise to its team

Goldwater, Dubé is pleased to announce the arrival of Me Carolyne Desormiers, a seasoned lawyer specializing in both family law, and in civil and commercial litigation to its team. Admitted to the Quebec Bar in 2011, Me Desormiers is an exceptional litigator whose...