Why is surrogacy illegal in Quebec?

Jan 11, 2018

While surrogacy is legally permitted in the country, Québec is different. Why is surrogacy illegal in Québec? Read on to learn more.

 

Surrogacy in Québec

 

In many parts of the world, families who are unable to conceive a child are able to turn to a surrogate mother to bring a child to term. But not here in Québec, where it’s against the law.

In Canada, laws regarding the legal status of family members—known as filiation—are set by the provinces. This means while surrogacy is legally permitted in the country, Québec is different.

Throughout Canada, it’s illegal to pay a surrogate directly. Her medical bills and other expenses can be paid for, but a surrogate mother cannot be directly compensated for carrying another’s child. Québec law goes further and doesn’t recognize the rights of the biological parents of a surrogate child at all.

In this province, when a baby is born, the birth mother must be listed as the mother on the birth certificate. Any contracts that a surrogate might have signed with another family are unenforceable.

 

Parental Rights over a Surrogate Child

 

To have any legal filiation rights over a surrogate child, a family would have to go through a formal adoption process. But there’s no guarantee they would be successful.

Originally, this was done to protect a woman’s right to control her own body and to uphold her reproductive rights. But it’s had the consequence of making it difficult for gay men to have children conceived through assisted reproduction. As reported recently in Global News, women who have difficulty carrying their own children to term are forced to look outside the province for a surrogate mother, paying medical bills out of their own pocket. In the case of that family, Melanie Parnass and her husband had to pay some $50,000 to have their surrogate mother give birth in Ontario, where surrogacy is permitted.

“I shipped my embryos from Montreal to Toronto and had to pay the clinic there,” Parnass told Global. “It’s a hard process. Emotionally, you’re putting your trust in someone else.”

 

Laws in Québec Surrounding Surrogacy

 

The laws in Québec around surrogacy are consistent with the law’s view of paternal parentage. When a baby is born, the birth mother can designate a father if she is unmarried; if married, the husband is presumed to be the father on the birth certificate. If the designated father takes up the responsibilities of parenthood, he’s legally considered to be the father and has filiation— this is known as “possession of status.” Even if a biological father then steps forward, this cannot be broken. This is based on the idea that a parental bond is more important to the wellbeing of a child than a biological one.

In 2015 the Quebec government’s Comité consultative sur le droit de la famille recommended the law be changed to allow for surrogates. But, so far, the provincial government has not changed the rules.

The law around surrogacy is a small part of filiation law, which determines who has legal rights over the upbringing of a child. Filiation governs all sorts of things, from who decides what sort of education a child receives, to who is eligible to inherit a parent’s property.

 

Have More Questions About Surrogacy? Contact Goldwater, Dubé

 

The Québec government introduced a new bill which, among other topics, also addresses surrogacy agreements. If the bill is passed, surrogacy agreements will be legally valid in Quebec. Moreover, parents could be legally recognized as the child’s parents without going through adoption. But certain conditions will have to be met.

If you think you might need our help with parental authority, or any other legal matter, contact Goldwater, Dubé to see if we can help.

Common law spouses: Me Goldwater meets the Minister of Justice

Goldwater, Dubé, a leader in Canadian family law since 1981, and its senior partner, Me Anne-France Goldwater, would like to thank Me Simon Jolin-Barrette, Québec Minister of Justice and Government House Leader, for meeting with the firm's founding partner on August...

Goldwater, Dubé welcomes senior litigator Me Daniel Romano

Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, and its founder, Me Anne-France Goldwater, are pleased to welcome Me Daniel Romano to its team of senior litigators. He is an established Montréal-based lawyer whose multidisciplinary practice, rigorous work...

Peace bond (article 810 of the Criminal Code)

In the complex world of Canadian law, the commitment to not disturb public order plays a crucial role. This commitment, more commonly known as "810," stems from Article 810 of the Criminal Code. The majority of cases involving crimes against a person, such as assault...

Longueuil Deer: Me Goldwater’s Arguments Against the Slaughter

Read the Court of Appeal judgment here. Goldwater, Dubé, a Canadian leader in family law since 1981, and its senior partner Me Anne-France Goldwater, will be heard by the Quebec Superior Court in the new year to defend a cause that continues to capture the public’s...